Maguire's - Senoia, Georgia

Deborah

We always love to try new restaurants and make a review the second time around. Well it was consistent..meaning it was GREAT the 2 times we've been there. Great atmosphere, spot on service,and the food was excellent ! We started today with the soft pretzels with Cheese and hot mustard. My husband got the Corned Beef and cabbage .Cooked perfectly and awesome flavor.I ate the Reuben Sandwich,which they used the fresh corned beef on it, with coleslaw. Excellent! And finally.. the warm brownie sundae ..that's big enough for 3 people ! Yummy!This is a restaurant we definitely will continue to eat at again .Kudos to the team!

Dwayne B.

Excellent food and atmosphere! You have to try the Bacon Bourbon Chicken and the Donut Burger! Our server was great! Save room for the Bread Pudding! Definitely worth trying while visiting the Senoia area! We will be back!

Andrew L. R.

Always a perfect spot! Maguire’s is my family’s favorite restaurant, for good reason. The service and food are always perfect, and my oldest boy in particular always asks is we can go to “the underground restaurant.”

Tonight, my boys were overtired and in rare form. The oldest was on the verge of a meltdown over a stolen gumball, and the staff felt bad for him and gave him a cookie. He immediately perked up, and said this is his FAVORITE place. He’s always loved it here, but the cookie was the icing on the cake. His younger brother (the gumball thief) ran from our
table to the checkerboard while the adults were eating. I dragged him back to the table, and didn’t realize he’d lost a shoe until a sweet staff member brought it back to us.

Every time we visit, it truly feels like visiting family. We do our best to make sure our kids aren’t being obnoxious, but the understanding and empathy we get when the kids are a little “off” is part of what keeps us coming back.

On top of all that, my very particular and very British father-in-law loves the food, and is consistently pleased with Maguire’s. If you’re looking for authenticity, his approval is the gold standard. I’m as American as it gets, and I love the food, too. My SIL is vegan, and can always find something suitable to eat, too. There’s truly something for everyone, and the vibes are spot-on for a true Irish pub.

Miranda M.

My new favorite place! We had Taylor as our server, and she was amazing! Friendly, helpful, and prompt. The food was fantastic! We really enjoyed the Scotch Eggs. The French Onion Soup was perfect, and their Sweet Potato Fries are amazing. We liked the laid back, comfortable atmosphere. It was a bit loud but when good people get together over great food and lovely cocktails, what else can you expect.

Chasity P.

I absolutely loved the establishment and decided to come in for their St. Patrick's day celebrations! I'm so glad we did. My friend and I both ordered the Guinness Lamb Stew, and I kid you not I teared up. Of course, everyone who knows me knows I'm sensitive anyway, 😂 but the dish was one of the best meals I've ever had in my life. It was a hearty stew with rosemary and thyme, and crisp rolls with rosemary as well. It tastes like early summer, home, comfort, and love. Ryan, our server, was so kind and authentic, as was the rest of the staff. Ryan told us that the owner makes nearly everything fresh in house, and that was reflected in the taste of the food. Thank you for the memories!

Sawman89

The fries were crispy and salty and fluffy. The lamb lollipops were sweet and a little spicy with an herbaciousness. And last but not least the bangers were rich and robust with a spectacular mustard sauce.

Tami M.

Stopped here for dinner on our way home from Alabama. It was way off of our path home, but it was well worth it. The cheesy spinach dip was a wonderful starter. Two of us got the fish & chips, and they were just lovely! The fish is white cod. My other friend got the Irish grilled cheese and French onion soup and loved it.
Our waiter was super friendly and very attentive, as was every staff person we encountered.
If you're ever in Senoia, make this stop. You won't regret it!

Nancy J.

This is our first time at Maguire’s. The food tastes like your grandmother made it! I had the cottage pie and my husband had the fish and chips. Both were delicious. The hostess, Wendy, was super friendly and made us feel like we were at home. Our server, Sydney, was helpful and attentive! Maguire’s is a great option if you are in the Senoia area.